Magic items: Player tools vs. plot coupons

 Maybe it's a knock-on effect of coming pretty close to death recently, or maybe it's just normal reminiscence, but I've been feeling a bit nostalgic lately for my very earliest days of acquaintance with D&D, back when I was first poring over the Moldvay Basic rulebook and taking in all the oddities and nuances of the game. For some reason, the scrolls of protection from the Magic Items chapter popped into my head. There was a scroll of protection from lycanthropes, and one of protection from undead. I think my players only ever acquired a couple of those in the entirety of our first campaigns, but if I recall correctly, they did get used.

Anyway, this gets me thinking about the differences between magic items as tools for skillful play, as they were no doubt originally intended, and magic items as plot coupons. 

A plot coupon is a thing a character or party must obtain to advance in a particular storyline, to pass some obstacle that would be either impossible or extremely difficult to surmount otherwise. It has a specific narrative purpose, even if it technically can be used in other situations or for other reasons. This, unfortunately, seems to be the most common way to use magic items in D&D, and has been for quite a while. If you find (or are given) a scroll of protection from undead, it's a virtual certainty there's some situation a short way down the (rail)road in which undead are a serious obstacle, and the party must overcome them to advance in the quest. Either it's blatantly obvious at which point they must employ the scroll, in which case the players have almost no agency, or they have to fret about whether the point has arrived and if they're using it prematurely, which I'll grant is some measure of agency, but hardly of an empowering sort. 

In contrast, that scroll of protection from undead can be a tool in the service of player agency if it is placed randomly, or simply because it tickles the DM's fancy, and has no specific purpose in this or any other adventure. Of course, there must be situations in which it would be useful, i.e. the presence or potential presence of undead in the setting, but beyond that, when and where to use it is entirely at the players' discretion. There is no "right" or "wrong" time. They could use it to get past a room full of skeletons to read the inscription on an altar. They might feel confident enough to crack open a sarcophagus they have a bad feeling about, knowing that if something jumps out at them, they have the scroll at the ready. They could use it to get out of a scrape with a nasty random encounter. They could also not use it in any of those situations. Maybe they'll find some other way to deal with those undead, or avoid them altogether, turning their backs on the inscription and sarcophagus to pursue other goals and keep that scroll for a rainy day. Whatever they do, it's their choice, and they get to feel the sense of accomplishment or disappointment for using it wisely or poorly, without ruining a storyline either way.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The good, the bad, and the ugly of B/X D&D

 With my B/X Monsters A to Z series ongoing, I've been focusing a lot on B/X D&D. Also, having mostly recovered from my heart attack and triple bypass surgery, we're hopefully going to reconvene our game group for the new year, and at some point I'll be taking my turn at DMing again, and I'm hankering for a good old fashioned sandbox campaign. So, I'm looking at sorting out my likes and dislikes (yes, there are a few) in good ol' B/X, in preparation for codifying some house rules and clarifications. I should make clear that I like far more than I dislike about the game, but as I ponder what changes I might wish to make, the dislikes are going to come to the fore. Like : Character generation. It's quick, easy, and there aren't an overwhelming amount of choices to be made. The most time-consuming part is buying equipment. Some players enjoy that part; for the rest, a small selection of pre-built equipment packages would be an easy fix. Like: The lack ...
Read more

Stuff you can do with an ascending AC and attack bonus-based combat paradigm

 Taking a break from the Monsters A to Z for some pondering on what you can do with some new old-school friendly combat mechanics. One of the strongest signs that Old School gaming is not simply about nostalgia is the extent to which old schoolers have embraced ascending Armor Class, in conjunction with class-based attack bonuses, over the old descending-AC-and-attack matrix or THAC0 system. It doesn't just streamline the math and eliminate a whole layer of fiddliness, though, as much as those effects are to be hailed. Within the ascending AC and attack bonus framework, you can do some pretty cool things that would have required some real mental gymnastics in the traditional system. The magic of this approach really lies in the use of an attack bonus stat rather than lines and columns in an attack matrix, which allows everyone to use the same target number for the same target.  To illustrate the point a bit more clearly, consider a 5th-level fighter and a 1st-level magic-user ...
Read more

What to do with treasure?

 In fantasy role-playing games, particularly those which link character advancement to recovery of treasure (of which practice, for the record, I am a fan and proponent), characters are going to accumulate a lot of silver, gold, and jewels over the course of an adventuring career. There is, unfortunately, a dearth of things on which to spend it in the rule books. At character creation and shortly thereafter, the focus is on the acquisition of basic adventuring gear. A newly-created PC may have to economize, especially on armor and weapons,but by second level, most of those concerns have been settled: a fighter who's accumulated enough treasure to gain his first level advancement has more than enough to purchase a suit of plate armor and his weapons of choice (if he hasn't already found magical versions) and probably a warhorse to boot. Mid-level characters may take interest in the "vehicles" section of the equipment roster, contemplating the purchase of ships or wagon...
Read more